My research so far: three reoccurring topics
Since beginning my exploration of how climate change is predicted to impact freshwater resource supply across Africa, I have found three reoccurring trains of thought within the literature. These are...
1. Climate change is predicted to affect freshwater resources differently: there is no uniform trend, especially when regarding the whole continent.
On the whole, Africa is expected to experience a future decrease in water availability, in which climate change is partly responsible (Niang et al., 2014). Reiterating on earlier posts, climate change will affect surface water and groundwater reserves differently; climate change is expected to affect surface water supplies greater than groundwater supplies, with some groundwater supplies even offering potential adaptation and resilience to climate change's impact on surface water supplies. Significantly, different parts of Africa will experience different types of impacts.
2. It's hard to predict how climate change will affect freshwater resources because there are some serious data issues, specifically absence of field data.
There is generally an inadequate amount of observational data in Africa, which leads to systematic limitations in proficiently estimating the availability of future freshwater supplies (Niang et al., 2014). There are absences in both temporal and spatial coverage of hydrogeological and hydrometrological observations: for instance, surface and groundwater hydrology is determined by various interacting drivers and factors, but due to the lack of reliable estimates of groundwater storage in Africa, there is a lack of quantitative understanding in the relationship between climate and groundwater recharge (Taylor et al., 2009; Taylor et al., 2012). Declining data quality and availability (e.g. Figure 2) has been widely declared in Africa and there is now a recognition that this problem must be dealt with order to assess sufficiently the problems related to climate change (e.g. Pitman, 2011).
Figure 1: Number of rainfall stations open each year in Africa (Pitman, 2011) |
3. Non-climatic factors, such as population growth and urbanisation, can significantly affect freshwater resource availability. These must be taken into account when predicting the availability of future freshwater resources.
Population growth, urbanisation, agricultural growth, and landuse change are expected with high confidence to all affect future freshwater availability. Climate change, conversely, is expected to only have a modest effect on future freshwater availability (Niang et al., 2014). There are many studies that show this. Beck and Bernauer (2011), for instance, concluded that non-climatic drivers (such as the ones above) are predicted to have a significant influence on future water availability in the Zambezi River Basin. Similarly, Droogers et al. (2012) found that climate change will only account for 22 percent of future water shortages in North Africa by 2050, compared to socioeconomic drivers causing 78 percent of the shortages.
All of these points keep being made, especially the latter two. But, Africa is a huge continent (three times the size of Europe!) so it can be hard to quantify, or even apprehend, all the factors that interact with climate change and its impact on freshwater security - I think it's time I focused in on a certain location in order to gain a greater understanding of this hugely complicated problem.
Hi Ruth! I have really enjoyed reading your blog so far and think that your three reoccurring trains of thought are quite interesting. When you speak about the absence of field data and how it must be dealt with, do you think this will be a priority when addressing the problems of climate change? From my impression, this is a vital factor when analysing and monitoring the future availability of freshwater supplies. But obviously, lack of funds and other aspects might cause problems into the future - what do you think?
ReplyDeleteHi Bailey - thanks for the comment! Yes! I completely agree with you - before researching the various topics I have covered in my blog, I naively didn't realise the extent of data inadequacy. It's something that really needs to be addressed, but I too suspect that lack of funding etc will impede this from happening. Unfortunately, I am a bit stuck on what to suggest! Do you have any suggestions?
DeleteUnfortunately, I think that this is an issue that is still causing many problems when it comes to water resource management. There's much more research now about this lack of hydrological data, so I think that the problem is being more recognised which is clearly quite a good start. However, I think there need to be many more thorough advances in order for the planning, design, and operation of complex water resource systems to be effective.
DeleteI find that when I read a paper, try to be critical of the data that is being used - I believe that this could give you many points for discussion that you might want to branch off into. I found a really nice paper by Boakye and Schultz (1994) of potential methods in 'filling in' this missing data which you might find useful. Even though it's quite an old paper, it summarises this issue quite nicely which effective illustrations. In my opinion, there clearly needs to be an increase in funding for hydrological monitoring (which I'm sure you would agree). But as a short-term solution, perhaps a focus on an efficient gap-filling methodology such as combining a local average with the sample mean which has proved quite effective in some cases (see Pappas et al., 2014 for example).
It's definitely not an easy topic to blog about, but I will look forward to seeing how you decide on a way forward over your next few posts.
Hope this helps,
Bailey
Links to the papers:
Boakye and Schultz (1994) - http://agris.fao.org/agris-search/search.do?recordID=GB19960063028
Pappas et al., (2014) - http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/2014JD021633/abstract
Thanks so much for these links! I'll give them a read and I'm sure the points you've made now will definitely emerge when I discuss how Africa can adapt to climate change and its impact on water scarcity.
Delete